We’ve been Venable fans in our house since the kids were little and we adored the Guinea P.I. books. I was so excited for her first middle grade graphic novel and this did not disappoint. First of all, there a ton of cats in this story. So many cats! With so many talents! I just thought it was hilarious. And the mystery of who’s the superhero and what’s happening is very enjoyable, too. I eagerly look forward to more. Bonus points for the yearbook style end pages where all the cats are listed with their talents, and they are amazing.
From the fantastic author of the terrific children’s series, Guinea P.I., here comes a full length YA graphic novel. Overall, I liked this very much, though I specifically preferred the second half of the book (when I felt like things really got moving, and I loved the ending as well as the author/illustrator interview.) There’s a bit of a family history mystery here that is sad and interesting and solid and informs much of the way her family acts. But then the main part of the story is a bit of self discovery, coming of age, type story. I want to click my “unlikable main character” box over there in my categories because I really, really could not stand Mads’s best friend, Cat. And I got so angry with Mads for not only remaining her friend, but also (to my mind) being inexplicably attracted to her! This was one of those stories where there were a few times I wanted to give the main character a good talking to about the choices she was making. I always think it’s good when the characters in a story provoke a strong reaction in the reader, so that’s not necessarily a negative.